A Canadian government lawyer told the hearing on Tuesday that the judge in Meng Wanzhou’s extradition hearing should reject the Huawei executive’s “exciting storey” about a conspiracy by Canadian and US authorities to violate her rights and dismiss an application to release her.
According to a written submission by government attorneys representing US interests in the case, the allegations of abuse were based solely on “speculation and innuendo.”
Meng’s lawyers have spent nearly five days in the Supreme Court of British Columbia in Vancouver arguing that her Canadian charter rights have been violated.
Get the most up-to-date information and commentary on the big stories coming out of China with our Global Impact newsletter.
They claimed the violations were carried out to aid the US Federal Bureau of Investigation in a “covert criminal investigation” of Meng, Huawei’s chief financial officer, and included illegal questioning by border officials as well as the seizure of her electronic devices and passwords.
On December 1, 2018, Meng was arrested at Vancouver’s airport on a US extradition warrant for fraud charges in New York.
Government lawyer Robert Frater told Associate Chief Justice Heather Holmes on Tuesday that she was being presented with “two starkly different narratives”.
“One is an exciting narrative. It involves a covert criminal investigation, witnesses lying on an almost industrial scale, and a cross-border cover-up,” said Frater, commencing the rebuttal to Meng’s abuse claims.
“The other narrative is more prosaic. It involves two sets of public officials going about their required tasks in circumstances where there was no playbook.”
Meng Wanzhou leaving her Vancouver home to attend a court hearing on Monday. Photo: AFP alt=Meng Wanzhou leaving her Vancouver home to attend a court hearing on Monday. Photo: AFP